Skip to content

Schmécké 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Cooler vs BLACK+DECKER 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Chiller, Mirrored Door

Glass door and wood shelves, or a narrow cabinet with a solid door?

Both are quiet thermoelectric coolers for 12 bottles. They differ in door, shelves and width.

Schmécké 12-bottle stainless thermoelectric wine cooler

Schmécké 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Cooler

8.2/10

Wins 1 of 6

Check price

≈ $220

BLACK+DECKER BD60336 12-bottle wine chiller with mirrored door

BLACK+DECKER 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Chiller, Mirrored Door

8.2/10

Wins 2 of 6

Check price

≈ $200

Point by point

Compared on 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Cooler 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Chiller, Mirrored Door
Range 46–64 °F 46–66 °F
Door Smoked tempered glass Solid mirrored
Shelves Oak wood 5 chrome racks
Width Not published 10 in
Warranty Not published 1 year parts and labor
Price when checked About $220 About $200
Listed on amazon.com Yes Yes

A tick marks the better answer on that line only. Counting ticks does not decide the page — the two verdicts below do, because these products answer different questions.

The one for you, of the two

Buy the 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Cooler

Choose the Schmécké to display bottles on oak shelves behind smoked glass.

Buy the 12-Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Chiller, Mirrored Door

Choose the BLACK+DECKER for a narrow gap and total darkness: it is 10 inches wide with a solid mirrored door.

What readers ask us

Why a solid door?

A solid door blocks all light, including UV, which protects the wine; the trade-off is that you cannot see the bottles.

Which has the wider temperature range?

They are close: the Schmécké covers 46 to 64 °F and the BLACK+DECKER 46 to 66 °F.

Which has a warranty?

BLACK+DECKER states one year for parts and labor. The Schmécké listing publishes no warranty.

What are the shelves made of?

Oak wood on the Schmécké; five chrome racks on the BLACK+DECKER.

The detail on each

Prices quoted in these summaries are dated readings. The live price is shown next to each product.